In This Article
💡 The Short Answer
- Secure meansThree things: private from the people you hand it to, accepted by the services you need, and hard to steal or lose. No single number does all three.
- App numbersGoogle Voice, MySudo and JMP hide your real number, but Capital One, Wells Fargo and Bank of America’s Zelle refuse VoIP numbers on their own help pages.
- Real linesA prepaid SIM or eSIM with its own number is listed as mobile, which is what these banks ask for. Put it in your own name. Lock it with a port-out PIN, and never let it lapse: a dropped number can go to a stranger after 45 to 90 days.
- Best moveGive banks a real mobile line, give strangers an app number, and use passkeys or an authenticator app instead of text codes wherever you can.

Bank of America’s Zelle FAQ names Google Voice outright. VoIP numbers, landlines and Google Voice numbers can’t be used to enroll. That one line explains why so many people end up with a second number that works fine for strangers and fails the moment a bank sends a code.
What you want the number to do decides which one to get. Below are the three kinds of number, who really controls each one, and how to keep the one that matters from being swapped, ported or recycled out from under you. This guide covers US numbers.
What Secure Really Means
| Test | The question | What usually fails it |
|---|---|---|
| Private | Can people you give it to find your real line? | Handing out your main number |
| Accepted | Will banks and apps send codes to it? | Many app numbers |
| Hard to take | Can someone swap, port or reclaim it? | Idle app numbers and unlocked carrier lines |
Most guides treat a secure number as one feature you can buy. It’s three, and they pull against each other. An app number is the most private option, because the person you text never sees your carrier line. It’s also the most likely to be refused by a bank, and the easiest to lose if you stop using it.
A carrier line is the reverse. Banks usually accept it, but it sits in your name, and anyone who can talk your carrier into a SIM change or a port-out can take it. So the honest answer to which number is secure is a question back: secure against what? Pick the risk you care about most, then pick the number.
Three Kinds of Number
| Kind | Private | Accepted | Hard to take |
|---|---|---|---|
| App number (VoIP) | Yes | Often refused | Depends on the app’s reclaim rules |
| Prepaid SIM or eSIM line | Yes, if kept separate | Usually listed as mobile | Only with a port-out PIN |
| Hardened carrier line | No, it’s in your name | Usually listed as mobile | Strongest of the three |
An app number lives on a company’s servers, not on a SIM. Google Voice, MySudo, Hushed, Burner and JMP all work this way. When you sign up somewhere, the service often runs your number through a carrier lookup first. Twilio’s lookup service labels an app number as nonFixedVoip, meaning a number obtained online without a physical device, and its documentation names Google Voice as an example.
A real mobile line is a prepaid SIM or an eSIM with its own number, from a carrier such as Tello, Mint Mobile or US Mobile. Lookups normally list it as mobile, the type banks ask for. A hardened carrier line is the same thing with every lock switched on: a port-out PIN, a number lock and extra ID checks for SIM changes. That’s the line to tie your bank and email to.
Who Owns Your Number
| Number | Who controls it | Can you port it out? |
|---|---|---|
| Google Voice | Google, under its terms | Yes, after a $3 unlock (free if you ported it in) |
| MySudo | Anonyome, the app’s maker | No port-out option found on its plans page |
| JMP.chat | JMP, while you pay | Yes, within 30 days of cancelling |
| Hushed, Burner | The app company | Hushed by support ticket; Burner yes |
| Carrier line | The carrier, in your name | Yes, with your account number and PIN |
Nobody owns a phone number outright. You rent it, and the question is what the landlord can do. With an app number, the company can suspend the account, change its terms or reclaim the number, and users report that appeals after a suspension often go nowhere. That pattern turns up again and again in reviews and forums, so treat any app number as a lease. Our second number apps guide covers each app’s reclaim rules and prices.
The exit door matters more than the price. Google charges $3 to unlock a Voice number for porting, according to its porting help page, and nothing if you brought the number in from a carrier. JMP keeps a cancelled number for 30 days so you can move it. A carrier line is the easiest to take with you, as long as you have the account number and the port-out PIN.
Will Your Bank Accept It
| Bank | What its own page says |
|---|---|
| Capital One | VOIP- or Wi-Fi- based services are not eligible to receive a code |
| Wells Fargo | Does not support text messages to landline or VoIP phones |
| Bank of America Zelle | VoIP, landline and Google Voice numbers are not eligible to enroll |
These are the banks’ own words, not guesses from a forum. Three big US banks refuse VoIP numbers for codes or enrollment on their help pages. That doesn’t mean every bank does, and Chase wasn’t checked, so don’t read the table as the whole industry. Google isn’t a bank, but its help pages point the same way: it limits how many accounts one number can create and advises against Voice numbers for Google account codes.
The odd part is the guidance itself. NIST SP 800-63B, NIST’s digital identity guidelines written for government systems, no longer forbids VoIP numbers in its latest revision. It treats text codes as a restricted option instead. NIST allows it, but plenty of services still refuse, because they make their own call on fraud risk. So if a number has to pass a bank, use a real mobile line and save the app number for everything else.
Your Options Compared
| Option | Good for | Main catch | Skip it if |
|---|---|---|---|
| Google Voice | A free US second number | Banks above refuse it; idle numbers get reclaimed | You need it for bank codes |
| MySudo | Separate numbers for separate parts of your life | The free plan has no number; codes can fail | You must keep the number for years |
| Hushed or Burner | Short-term numbers you plan to drop | Paid; see our app guide for prices. Burner’s separate Verified Number add-on “acts like” mobile, the vendor says | You want a long-lived number |
| JMP.chat, or VoIP.ms for SIP users | A US or Canadian number for $4.99 a month, checked in November | US and Canada only; JMP runs through a Jabber chat app; VoIP.ms needs real setup | You want a normal dialer app |
| Prepaid line | A real mobile number from Tello, Mint Mobile or US Mobile | Needs a SIM or eSIM slot; check plan pages for prices | You have no spare SIM or eSIM slot |
| Efani | People who fear a SIM swap above all | $99 a month; protections are the company’s own claims | Most people, given the price |
| Travel eSIM | Data abroad | Many are data-only, with no number | You need a number |
Nothing in this table is ranked, because the right row depends on what you’re protecting. Google Voice is free for personal use in the US, but you need a US number to set it up, and Google now requires a new Voice user to verify identity with a legal name, government ID and address before the number works. MySudo gives you several numbers on paid plans and none on the free one. JMP describes itself as a free and open source VoIP provider; it keeps its numbers to the US and Canada.
For a number banks accept, look at a prepaid line instead of another app. US Mobile’s port-in promotion excludes number brokers and VoIP services, a hint at how carriers see app numbers too. Efani sells a carrier line built around SIM-swap defense, and says it adds a 14-day cooling-off period before a port-out. Many travel eSIMs sell data only, so check before you buy one from our eSIM apps list as a second number.
How Numbers Get Recycled
| Stage | What happens |
|---|---|
| An app number goes idle | Google may reclaim a free Voice number after 3 months without calls or texts, and gives 45 days to get it back |
| You cancel a paid app number | JMP reclaims it 30 days after cancellation unless you port it out |
| You close a carrier line | Federal rules let carriers hold a residential number for 45 to 90 days before giving it out again |
| The number finds a new owner | Anything still linked to it, from a bank to a shop account, now texts a stranger |
Under FCC aging rules, a disconnected residential number goes back into the pool after 45 to 90 days. In an earlier study, Princeton researchers sampled 259 available numbers at two carriers and found 215 had been recycled. 171 of the 259 still had a linked account with at least one of six big sites, including Amazon, Google and PayPal, and 100 were linked to leaked login credentials.
App numbers follow their own clock, and each company sets it: the first two rows of the table above show Google’s and JMP’s. The FCC also keeps a reassigned numbers database, but it’s built for businesses that call and text, not for the sign-up form at your bank.
SIM Swaps and Port-Outs
What the FCC rules do and do not settle
- The FCC adopted rules that will require carriers to verify a customer before a SIM change or a port-out, once a compliance date is set.
- No compliance date appears in the federal rule text we read, so don’t assume your carrier already follows them.
- Until then, the protection you get is whatever your carrier offers: a port-out PIN, a number lock or extra ID checks.
A SIM swap moves your number to a SIM card the attacker holds. A port-out moves it to a different carrier. Either way, your texts and calls go to them, along with every code your bank sends. NIST’s latest guidance tells services to treat a recent SIM change or port as a warning sign when they send codes.
An app number has no SIM to swap, a point MySudo’s maker makes in its own marketing. The account behind it becomes the target instead, so a weak password on your Google account puts your Voice number at risk too. Efani says its line adds 11 layers of verification and up to $5 million in insurance against SIM-swap losses. We found no published policy terms, so treat both as the company’s claims.
Stronger Than SMS Codes
- Add a passkey or a FIDO security key wherever a service offers one.
- Use an authenticator app for accounts that don’t support passkeys yet.
- Keep text codes as the last option, and remove the SMS fallback once something stronger works.
- Set a port-out PIN or number lock on the carrier line you keep.
The safest number for codes is no number at all. CISA warns plainly in its mobile guidance: don’t use SMS as a second factor. It calls FIDO the only phishing-resistant option and accepts passkeys. A text code can be phished or redirected by a SIM swap, and a passkey can’t be read off a screen and typed into a fake site.
Leaving SMS as a backup undoes most of the work, because attackers go for the weakest door. Once a passkey or authenticator works, find the recovery settings and remove the phone number. Our guide to securing your Android phone covers the device side: screen lock and app permissions.
Moving a Number Safely
- Don’t cancel the old service first. The port closes the old account for you.
- Get the account number and port-out PIN from the provider you’re leaving.
- For Google Voice, pay the $3 unlock before you start (free for numbers you ported in).
- Check the new provider accepts your kind of number. Google Voice takes mobile numbers only.
- Keep the old SIM in the phone until calls ring on the new service.
Don’t port your bank number into Google Voice. It turns the line into a VoIP number that these banks refuse, and it’s then only as safe as your Google account.
Porting is how you keep a number when you change providers, and the order of steps matters. Cancel first and the number starts its reclaim or aging clock, and you may lose it. Google charges $20 to port a mobile number into Voice and says the move can take up to 48 hours, with texts taking up to 3 business days. JMP says its port-ins normally take 1 to 2 weeks.
Expect a gap where texts arrive late or not at all. Don’t schedule a bank login or a password reset for that window. When the new service rings and texts arrive, send yourself a test code from one account you can afford to lock, then move the rest.
Before You Drop One
Before you cancel or abandon a number
- List every account that sends codes or recovery texts to it: banks, email, Google, Apple, WhatsApp, social apps.
- Move each one to a passkey, an authenticator app or the number you’re keeping.
- Remove the old number as a recovery option, not just as a login method.
- Save any texts or voicemails you need.
- If you can, port the number to a cheap plan instead of cancelling it.
Dropping a number is where the damage shows up, often months later. The account you forgot about still points to the old number, the number goes to someone new after the aging period, and a password reset lands on a stranger’s phone. The Princeton findings above are exactly that: available numbers still tied to a previous owner’s accounts.
The checklist takes an evening. Start with email, since it resets everything else, then the bank, then anything with stored cards. If the number is old and tied to too much to unpick, parking it on a cheap prepaid plan costs less than one account takeover.
Who Sees What
| Who | App number | Carrier line |
|---|---|---|
| People you text | The app number only | Your real number |
| Line-type lookups | Labelled VoIP | Usually labelled mobile, with the carrier |
| The provider | Your account details and call and text logs | Your name, billing details and logs |
| Your phone’s carrier | Data traffic to the app | Every call and text |
An app number hides you from the people you give it to. It doesn’t hide you from the company running it, which still keeps your account details and logs. Google now requires a new Voice user to verify identity with a legal name, government ID and address before the number works, and MySudo needs ID for UK numbers. A paid number in a different name from your carrier line still isn’t anonymous.
Ordinary texts aren’t end-to-end encrypted either way. JMP says its own end-to-end encryption only works between two Jabber users. So treat a second number as a shield against people, not against the companies in the middle. For private conversations, move them to an encrypted messaging app once you trust the person.
Public receive-SMS sites are the least private option of all: they show every code to anyone who opens the page, and anyone can later reset an account tied to that number. Our guide to online numbers and Bumble covers what works instead.
How This Was Researched
Method
- Research-based evaluation from official pricing and help pages, terms, store listings and user reports, checked in November.
- No hands-on verification tests were run, and no accounts were created.
Every price and rule above comes from the provider’s or regulator’s own page, read in November, or from a published study. Bank stances come from each bank’s help pages, quoted as written. Where a company describes its own security, such as Efani’s insurance or MySudo’s point about SIM swaps, the guide says so, because nobody outside the company has verified those claims.
User reports, such as suspensions with no working appeal and codes that never arrive, are labelled as reports. They recur across reviews and forums, but they’re not the same as a company policy. Prices and plan rules change often, so check the linked page before you pay for anything.
Bottom Line
Bank of America’s Zelle FAQ was the warning at the top, and it holds for most people: one number can’t be private, accepted and impossible to take all at once. Split the jobs. Keep one real mobile line for banks and email, lock it with a port-out PIN, and give everyone else an app number you can afford to lose.
Then make the number matter less. Passkeys and an authenticator app take codes off the phone line entirely, and that protects you whichever number you keep. Before you drop any number, move every account off it first.
Key Takeaways
- Split the jobsA real mobile line for banks and email; an app number for people you don’t know well.
- Banks and VoIPCapital One, Wells Fargo and Bank of America’s Zelle refuse VoIP numbers on their own pages.
- Lock the lineSet a port-out PIN; the FCC’s SIM-swap rules have no compliance date in the rule text we read.
- RecyclingA dropped carrier number can go to someone else after 45 to 90 days, with your old accounts still attached.
- CodesUse passkeys or an authenticator app, and remove SMS as a recovery option.
















